Jared Padalecki shot against a blue seamless wearing a black suit with a denim button-down shirt.

Rory Gilmore’s first love. A paranormal investigator. A Texas Ranger. A SoCal firefighter. A washed-up superhero. Jared Padalecki has long been a beloved staple on our TV screens, so when we heard the actor was starring in one of Netflix‘s new original Christmas movies—with Leighton Meester, our Gossip Girl queen, no less—our merry hearts skipped a beat.

In Guarding Stars, based on Katherine Center’s contemporary romance novel The Bodyguard, Padalecki plays A-list action star Jack Stapleton, who finds himself in a fake-dating predicament with his female bodyguard Hannah Brooks (Meester) while spending Christmas with his family at their Montana ranch. Naturally, hijinks ensue and sparks fly in what is a delightfully cozy and fun new holiday classic.

While it can’t possibly get more meta than an actor playing an actor who is acting (in a pretend relationship), the role didn’t come as naturally to Padalecki as one might think. Ahead, we talk to the actor about his megastar inspirations for Jack, showing a different side of himself through this role, and being perfectly fine with never being in front of the camera again.

Latest Videos FromWho What Wear

Jared Padalecki shot against a blue seamless wearing a black suit with denim button-down shirt.

This film is so different from your previous work. What excited you about doing a holiday movie?